"Oooooh," she said, nodding. "The one that looks like an old teacher we had here."

Ino had been on the island long enough to not assume people were the same even if they looked it. Also, the fact the he was a student was a pretty big tip off that it was a different (version?) person.

"He's cuuute," Ino teased. "From your world? Or just a new friend?"